Introduction
The atmosphere in an MLS stadium can be transformative. It’s more than just a place to watch a game; it’s a cauldron of passion, a stage for unforgettable moments, and a vital element in the growing identity of Major League Soccer. From the intimate, soccer-specific havens to the grand, multi-purpose arenas, MLS stadiums represent a diverse landscape of sporting venues, each with its own unique character and contribution to the league. But with such variety, how do they stack up against each other? Which stadiums truly elevate the MLS experience, and which fall short of the mark?
This article dives into the heart of MLS, exploring the league’s stadiums and ranking them from best to worst. We’ll consider a range of factors, including the all-important atmosphere, the architectural design, the accessibility and location, the quality of amenities (food, beverage, restrooms), sightlines from various seating areas, the overall comfort of the venue, and even historical significance where applicable. Our goal is to provide a comprehensive and objective assessment of each stadium, highlighting the best (and occasionally the worst) that MLS has to offer, and ultimately crown the champion of MLS stadiums.
The Pinnacle of Passion: Top Tier MLS Stadiums
Let’s start with the elite, the venues that consistently deliver an unparalleled soccer experience. These stadiums are more than just places to watch a game; they are integral parts of the city’s cultural fabric.
Providence Park (Portland Timbers)
Providence Park, home of the Portland Timbers, consistently ranks among the best soccer venues in North America, and it deserves its place at the top. The Timbers Army, one of the most passionate and dedicated fan groups in MLS, creates an electric atmosphere that is unmatched. The stadium itself, steeped in history and tradition, offers excellent sightlines and a unique, intimate feel. Located in the heart of Portland, it’s easily accessible and surrounded by vibrant bars and restaurants. While it may lack some of the modern amenities of newer stadiums, the raw passion and unparalleled atmosphere more than compensate. A recent renovation modernized some facilities while maintaining the historical charm. Providence Park is, simply put, an MLS treasure.
Audi Field (D.C. United)
Audi Field has revitalized the soccer scene in the nation’s capital. Purpose-built for soccer, it offers excellent sightlines throughout the stadium. Located in the Buzzard Point neighborhood, the stadium is easily accessible via public transportation. The design is modern and sleek, and the amenities are top-notch, with a wide variety of food and beverage options. While the atmosphere may not be quite as consistently fervent as Providence Park, the supporters’ groups are growing, and the stadium is becoming a true home for D.C. United fans.
Exploria Stadium (Orlando City SC)
Exploria Stadium in Orlando provides a truly unique experience. The purple aesthetic is instantly recognizable, and the north end is a designated safe-standing supporters section, generating a vibrant and loud atmosphere. The stadium is centrally located in downtown Orlando, making it easily accessible. The design is modern and sleek, and the amenities are well-maintained. The canopy roof helps to amplify the sound and provide shade, making it a comfortable experience even on hot Florida days. While it is sometimes criticized for the surrounding neighborhood, there is a noticeable improvement. Overall, Exploria Stadium is a shining example of a well-designed and fan-focused MLS stadium.
Solid Performers: Mid-Tier MLS Stadiums
These stadiums provide a good overall experience, with decent amenities and generally positive atmospheres. They may lack some of the unique characteristics of the top-tier stadiums, but they still offer a solid game-day experience.
Allianz Field (Minnesota United FC)
Allianz Field is a stunning, state-of-the-art stadium. Designed specifically for soccer, it boasts excellent sightlines and a modern aesthetic. The stadium’s exterior is particularly striking, and the amenities are top-notch. Located in St. Paul, it’s a bit further from downtown Minneapolis, but it is easily accessible via public transportation. The atmosphere is steadily improving as the club builds its fanbase. While it may lack the historical charm of some older stadiums, Allianz Field is a beautiful and well-designed venue.
Children’s Mercy Park (Sporting Kansas City)
Children’s Mercy Park has consistently been praised for its intimate atmosphere and excellent sightlines. The stadium is located in Kansas City, Kansas, and offers a range of amenities. The supporters’ groups are passionate and create a lively environment. While it may not be the newest stadium in the league, it is well-maintained and provides a solid game-day experience.
Lower.com Field (Columbus Crew)
Lower.com Field is a modern stadium that offers a great fan experience. Located in the Arena District of Columbus, it’s easily accessible. The stadium features a canopy that covers the stands and amplifies the crowd noise. It offers good sightlines and a range of amenities.
Areas for Improvement: Lower-Tier MLS Stadiums
These stadiums often face challenges in terms of atmosphere, design, amenities, or location. While they may still offer a decent game-day experience, there is room for improvement.
Gillette Stadium (New England Revolution)
Gillette Stadium, home of the New England Revolution, is primarily a football stadium, and that unfortunately impacts the soccer experience. The vast size of the stadium can dilute the atmosphere, and the sightlines are not ideal for soccer. Located far outside of Boston, accessibility can be a challenge. While the Revolution have a dedicated fanbase, the stadium simply doesn’t provide the intimate and passionate environment that is typical of the league’s best soccer-specific venues. It’s hard for the atmosphere to permeate when sections are often empty.
Soldier Field (Chicago Fire FC)
Soldier Field, another historic venue primarily designed for football, presents similar challenges to Gillette Stadium. The large size and design make it difficult to create an intimate soccer atmosphere. While the Chicago Fire have a dedicated fanbase, the stadium doesn’t lend itself to a vibrant soccer experience. Sightlines can be an issue depending on seating location.
The Importance of Atmosphere: Providence Park’s Secret Sauce
What is it about Providence Park that makes it so special? It’s more than just the history or the location; it’s the atmosphere. The Timbers Army, with their chants, flags, and unwavering support, creates a wall of sound that truly impacts the game. The stadium design, with its steep stands and close proximity to the field, amplifies the noise and creates a sense of intimacy. But it’s also the culture of the city itself. Portland is a soccer-mad city, and the passion for the Timbers is palpable. The combination of these factors makes Providence Park a truly unique and unforgettable soccer venue.
Architectural Innovation: The Beauty of Allianz Field
Allianz Field stands out for its architectural design. The stadium’s exterior is clad in a translucent polymer mesh, which is illuminated at night, creating a stunning visual effect. The interior is equally impressive, with its steep stands and excellent sightlines. The design is both modern and functional, creating a comfortable and enjoyable experience for fans. The roof design enhances the sound while protecting fans from the elements.
Looking Ahead: The Future of MLS Stadiums
The trend in MLS is clearly towards soccer-specific stadiums that are designed to create a more intimate and engaging fan experience. New stadiums like CITYPARK, home of St. Louis City SC, are raising the bar in terms of design, amenities, and atmosphere. These venues are not just places to watch a game; they are integral parts of the city’s fabric, contributing to the local economy and fostering a sense of community. The use of safe standing supporters sections and the design of unique premium experiences are also gaining popularity.
The development of new stadiums is having a significant impact on the growth and perception of MLS. These venues are attracting new fans, generating revenue, and enhancing the league’s reputation as a major player in the global soccer landscape. Furthermore, many teams are increasingly focused on making stadiums hubs for the community, through providing public use space, such as fields, that foster a sense of shared engagement. This further entrenches the teams within their locality.
Conclusion: Ranking the Experience
Ranking MLS stadiums is a complex undertaking, as each venue has its own unique strengths and weaknesses. While some stadiums clearly stand out in terms of atmosphere, design, and amenities, others have room for improvement. Ultimately, the best MLS stadiums are those that provide an immersive, engaging, and unforgettable experience for fans.
MLS stadiums play a crucial role in the overall success of the league. They are the heart and soul of the clubs, and they provide a platform for the growth and development of the sport in North America. As MLS continues to evolve, we can expect to see even more innovative and impressive stadiums that will further enhance the fan experience.
Do you agree with our ranking? Let us know your favorite (and least favorite) MLS stadiums in the comments below! What improvements would you like to see in MLS stadiums? Share your thoughts and join the conversation!
